Critique of Chapter 6 of the National Standard for Organic and Biodynamic Produce

The National Standard for Organic and Biodynamic Produce
The National Standard for Organic and Biodynamic Produce is Australia’s technical export standard for organic and bio-dynamic goods. It is given effect through Australia’s export regulatory framework for organic goods intended for export. The National Standard may also be used voluntarily by producers supplying the domestic market who wish to market their goods as meeting the Standard. Chapter 6 of the National Standard (Edition 3.8, 2015, last updated 2022) apparently regulates raw or bulk imported organic produce, because it may be repackaged or further processed and recertified to carry a logo from a DAFF approved Australian organic Certification Body and be re-exported from Australia. Some confusion about organic claims on imported goods arises from branded products (jams, sauces etc.) that cannot be excluded from imports because of WTO rules. Article 3 of GATT relates to national treatment and requires that imported goods should not be subject to discrimination when compared to locally produced goods. In other words, countries may not impose more restrictive standards for imported goods. This means that in the absence of a domestic regulation, Australia is prevented from banning the import of produce labelled with a foreign organic label. To attempt such a limitation would be perceived at a trade restriction, until such time as the ban can be established based on a consistent export and domestic regulation. This implies that, if there are no legally-binding domestic standards, any imports labelled as organic – and produced in whatever way – can be legally imported and called ‘organic’. It can be safely assumed that neither the government nor the organic industry is interested in making the domestic organic industry uncompetitive in this way. (Wynen and Clay, 2018). The most frequently encountered foreign label is the USDA organic seal. USDA NOP allows hydroponic production and some different inputs such as soluble mined Sodium Nitrate. Most organic standards around the world prohibit hydroponic production, and consumer organisations in the USA have mounted a strong challenge to the standard to again prohibit organic hydroponics. Canada includes a clause in their equivalence agreement with the USA that excludes hydroponic methods for NOP certified goods imported into Canada. Domestic Australian organic regulation could similarly protect local consumers from this production method and require a conformity assessment process for imported organic produce before it could be sold in Australia. That is, specified production methods may be excluded from mutual recognition arrangements. Any proposed Australian domestic organic regulation should require a comprehensive side-by-side standards comparison and analysis prior to agreeing to equivalency arrangements with other country regimes. Such arrangements commonly include exclusions for certain categories of product that are not compliant with local standards.   The status of imported certified organic products in November 2026 Industry rumours suggest that some imported bulk products are fumigated upon entry but still make their way into organic markets (pers. comms. with organic traders and government biosecurity officers, 2016 and 2019), in contradiction to clause 6.1.6. There are imported processed products that display certification marks from other countries, but there is no effective control on those products. Without standards equivalence agreements in place between Australian and other countries, consumers cannot be sure that imported products comply with the National Standard. Although the Competition and Consumer Act of 2010 should apply to imported product, and would be applied to such products if they did not meet safety standards, in the absence of domestic regulation, it is unlikely that authorities can effectively deal with organic claims on imported products where they are not compliant with the National Standard and they would only come to the attention of authorities if they are reported by Australian certification bodies or consumers. Chapter 6 of the National Standard is exemplary of problems in drafting the standard, in the absence of domestic regulation. Chapter 6 deals only with raw or bulk produce. Clause 6.1.1. is not explicit that the standard does not control domestic products bearing a label from another country, but it is the interpretation of authorities responsible for managing movement of produce through the wharf (or airfield). 6.1.1 Organic or bio-dynamic produce which is imported into Australia can be labelled as meeting this Standard provided the produce satisfies the following requirements: a. a competent authority and/or government approved certification organisation has issued export documentation; stating the consignment has been produced under a system that is equivalent to this Standard; or b. the certification organisation is recognised by the importing country competent authority; and c. was subject to a regular system of inspection by a competent authority approved certification organisation; and d. does not contain any substances not permitted by this Standard. (National Standard Edition 3.8) The extract above is unchanged since Edition 1. The original drafters knew that the standard did not apply to the domestic market but believed that it would be adopted into legislation in some form, as stated by Minister Kerin when he announced the establishment of OPAC in 1990. The intention for the standard to apply to the domestic market was repeated by Minister Crean when he launched the standard in 1992, and by AQIS officers Erwin and Lovisolo on numerous public platforms (some are listed at Appendix 4). The intent of the OPAC committee (which drafted edition 1) for Chapter 6 of the National Standard was to deal with produce entering the country that might be subject to further processing and labelling, or otherwise exported again. Clause 6.1.2. could leave the uniformed (common) reader with the view that the National Standard has legal force in the domestic market when it does not. Its application is limited to produce that will be re-exported. 6.1.2 Imported organic or bio-dynamic produce can be labelled as meeting this Standard provided that the operator (importer) is certified and the imported products comply with 6.1.1. Additionally, Clauses 6.1.3 and 6.1.4. relate to an export certificate issued by a competent authority or government approved certification body in another country, and 6.1.6 refers to exclusion of product treated with a fumigant at the wharf. 6.1.6 Following any pre or post entry quarantine chemical or ionising radiation treatments an operator must not label imported organic or bio-dynamic produce as meeting this Standard. In these situations all organic or bio-dynamic trade descriptions must be either de-faced or stencilled-over or destroyed. Organic Consumers Association of Australia (OCAA) investigations and personal communication with biosecurity staff during normal industry business suggests that imported product is sometimes not inspected by biosecurity officers, or when fumigated, no action is taken to ensure that in does not continue to be part of the organic chain of custody. Certification bodies could ensure beyond doubt that non-compliant produce is not labelled as organic if they insist that in each case of imported produce, the wharf-side documentation relevant to treatment and handling of the consignment is provided to the certification office. It is no longer a requirement that certification bodies insist upon (pers comms. with certification officers from several certification bodies). Government accreditation audits of the certification bodies relate to re-exported produce, consistent with the government position that it is not responsible for domestic control. Once again, consumers are left without any certainty that the very large quantity of imported produce that is either repackaged or processed and labelled with an Australian organic logo, is genuinely in conformity with the organic standards (whichever one they bear in the retail space). OCAA asks, is this the certification cabal at work to protect traders and certification fees rather than genuine consumer interests? The solution is straightforward: inspect every consignment and insist that clearance certifications for each consignment are provided to the certification body and acted upon.  

Wynen, E., & Clay, L. (2018, February). Roadmap for Australia’s organic industry: A legal

domestic standard. Paper circulated to Australian Organic Industry Working Group by the

authors prior to the Love Organic meeting in Canberra.

https://www.organicoperators.au/node/222

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top